Are you familiar with closed user groups within the travel industry and how they help consumers find the best online discounts possible? These groups originated in the telecom industry and referred to a simple platform which allowed paying subscribers the opportunity to make free calls within the group. Essentially, the very same tactic can still be found within that industry through a service in which telecom operators offer free calls to members on the same network.
Closed User Groups within the Travel Industry
Closed User Groups in the travel industry were the only way to find online travel discounts prior to the internet. Hotels Etc and a number of other travel membership clubs were inundated with applications and requests at the time from consumers who want to pay less for their travel needs. In a similar fashion to the above mentioned telecom companies, Hotels Etc offered their subscribing members the opportunity to avail of huge discounts within a closed user group. Hotels Etc negotiated the discount – their members saved money.
But why are these travel membership clubs suddenly so important?
Travel clubs have always been important but the arrival of the online world and search booking engines in particular meant it was easy for consumers to find the best travel deals without them. But history does repeat itself in every market and with the introduction of a new law called rate parity, we are now seeing the re-emergence of travel membership clubs.
You see, the law of rate parity now restricts traditional booking engines from offering genuine discounts or value to their customers. Stipulating that every booking engine, whether this is Orbitz, Expedia or anything similar, must display the same cost across all channels of distribution which effectively means they cannot advertise the heavily discounted prices we have seen in the past.
Hotels Etc and the ease of booking
Hugely popular in the early 1990’s, finding discounts with a travel club is really a straight forward process. Having negotiated the best discounts direct with the supplier, travel clubs then offer these heavily discounted vacations or travel services to their members in return for a small subscription. And the best part of this system? Closed user groups are exempt from the laws of rate parity and they are not restricted in any way from passing these discounts on to their customers.
As mentioned, these travel clubs are re-emerging and in contrast to the very beginning of online booking, they now offer all of the perks (and more) of a traditional booking engine. Fast and straight forward, accessing the best online discounts with a travel club could not be easier.
Morale of the story: For many years, travel booking engines led the charge in terms of finding the best prices for hotels and vacations in particular but recent laws have restricted these traditional booking engines from providing any real value. If you want genuine value, travel club membership is now the only real option to find the best online discounts.
For two decades there was never really any secret in terms of how to get travel discounts online, for it was once an easy task. Simply log on to Expedia, Orbitz or any of the other most prominent booking engines and take your pick. There was really no catch to any of this process either; you got the best products and services at the best possible price every, single time. Suppliers and operators were more than happy to avail of these extra avenues for filling their vacant hotel rooms, especially at the last minute, and the process itself was so convenient it left potential guests with no good reason not to utilize their services.
How to get travel discounts online
In fact, the presence of travel discounts online continued to increase for many years, as did the actual percentage of these offers. More and more, new travel booking engines found their way into the market and this did nothing other than make it easier for customers to find the best deals.
Old ways and new beginnings
However, it has long been known that history repeats itself within every industry or market, and the online travel industry is no different. Hugely popular and common place prior to the arrival of the internet, Travel Clubs were once the main and only source of travel discounts. In return for a small membership fee, these membership clubs negotiated special rates with suppliers and offered these amazing deals back to their members in what is called a “Closed User Group”. In many ways, these were no different to a traditional booking engine from a few years ago in that they offered large discounts with no catch.
Interestingly, these travel membership clubs were overshadowed by the emergence of the online world and in particular, booking engines. But as mentioned, history does repeat itself and in light of a new law introduced to the market called “Rate parity”, these travel clubs are now re-emerging as the best and only way to find travel discounts.
Rate Parity and Travel membership clubs
Rate Parity is a new law which essentially disallows the traditional booking engines from advertising reduced prices across their channels of distribution or in simple English, they no longer offer discounts of any kind. This may sound very significant but that’s because it is and if you check any of these booking engines against each other, you will quickly find the prices are the same across the board.
Naturally this means the consumer is offered no real value from a traditional booking engine other than convenience and for this reason, Travel Membership Clubs are thriving once more. Exempt from the laws of “Rate Parity”, these membership clubs are now offering genuine travel discounts to their members which cannot be found anywhere else online.
Although maybe you need convincing and in such case, you should consider starting a free trial offer with Hotels Etc, the leading Travel Membership Club in North America. With more than 4 million members, 25 years of experience and a five star rating; Hotels Etc is now one of the best and only ways to get travel discounts online.
Originally published January 29, 2017 | Updated August 2026
Hotel rate parity generally refers to contractual provisions, pricing practices or distribution arrangements affecting how certain hotel rates are advertised or distributed across specified sales channels. It is not one universal worldwide law. Publicly advertised rates and eligible private member offers can operate differently, especially when access is restricted to authenticated members or other qualified users.
Hotel distribution can include publicly advertised rates as well as eligible private member offers available through restricted channels.
What Is Hotel Rate Parity?
Hotels distribute rooms through many channels, including their own websites, online travel agencies, travel professionals, wholesalers and private membership platforms.
Hotel rate parity generally refers to contractual provisions, pricing practices or distribution arrangements concerning how certain hotel rates are advertised or distributed across specified sales channels.
Historically, these arrangements have often been described as rate-parity agreements or rate-parity clauses.
It is important not to describe rate parity as one universal worldwide law. Contracts, competition laws, regulations and court decisions can differ by jurisdiction, and the legal treatment of rate-parity provisions has changed over time.
Is Hotel Rate Parity a Law?
No, not as one universal law that applies the same way everywhere.
Rate parity commonly refers to contractual provisions and hotel distribution practices. Laws and regulations affecting those arrangements differ among countries and jurisdictions.
Some jurisdictions have restricted certain types of rate-parity clauses, while contractual arrangements between hotels and distribution partners can also vary.
For that reason, statements such as “rate parity is a worldwide law” or “private travel clubs are universally exempt from rate-parity laws” are too broad and can be misleading.
Why Do Hotel Prices Sometimes Look Similar on Different Websites?
Travelers sometimes search the same hotel, room type and travel dates across several public booking websites and see identical or very similar prices.
There can be many reasons for this, including hotel pricing strategies, inventory, distribution agreements and market conditions.
However, seeing similar publicly advertised prices does not necessarily mean every travel platform has access to exactly the same inventory, pricing or member benefits.
There is an important distinction between a hotel rate available openly to the general public and an eligible offer distributed through a private or restricted channel.
Public Hotel Rates vs. Private Member Rates
Public Hotel Rates
Public hotel rates are generally visible without requiring a traveler to belong to a particular private membership program or authenticated group.
They may be displayed on hotel websites, online travel agencies and other publicly accessible booking platforms.
Private Member Offers
Private offers may be available to eligible members of membership programs, loyalty programs, corporate programs or other qualified groups.
Access may require authentication, membership or another form of eligibility.
Private pricing does not automatically mean that every hotel will always be cheaper. The key distinction is access to another category of eligible offers that may not be distributed in the same manner as unrestricted public pricing.
Travelers should compare the complete offer, including rates, room types, taxes, fees, cancellation terms and eligible member benefits.
What Is a Closed User Group?
A Closed User Group, commonly referred to as a CUG, is a defined group of eligible users who can access certain offers within a restricted environment.
Membership, authentication or another eligibility requirement typically distinguishes the private environment from unrestricted public access.
This concept is important when understanding private travel membership programs.
Simple CUG Explanation
Public pricing: Generally viewable by anyone.
Private member offer: Available to eligible or authenticated users.
Closed User Group: A defined group whose eligibility separates the private environment from unrestricted public access.
Hotels Etc. operates as a private membership program. Eligible members access the membership environment using their credentials and can search participating travel offers based on destination, dates, supplier availability and other booking conditions.
Do Private Member Rates Always Mean Lower Prices?
No.
Private access does not mean every hotel, destination and travel date will always produce a lower price than every publicly available offer.
Hotel pricing is dynamic and can change because of:
Hotel occupancy
Destination
Travel dates
Seasonality
Special events
Demand
Room type
Available inventory
Cancellation terms
Refundability
Supplier availability
Temporary promotions
The value of private travel membership is access to eligible private offers and participating benefits that may not otherwise be available through a normal unrestricted public search.
Why Can’t Every Private Member Offer Be Displayed Publicly?
If an offer is distributed specifically to eligible users through a private environment, displaying that same offer openly to everyone could eliminate the distinction between public and restricted distribution and may conflict with applicable supplier or distribution requirements.
That is why some travel offers may require membership authentication or another qualification before the traveler can access or book them.
This type of private-rate structure is not unique to Hotels Etc. Major hotel distribution platforms also recognize private rates that are available only to eligible groups or loyalty members.
For an example of how private hotel rates can be handled within a major hotel distribution ecosystem, see Google’s official information about conditional and private hotel rates.
How Does Hotels Etc. Fit Into Private Travel Distribution?
Hotels Etc. has been serving members since 1996.
Hotels Etc. provides eligible members access to a private travel and lifestyle discount membership environment.
Rather than describing Hotels Etc. as operating through a “loophole” or claiming that the company is universally “exempt from rate-parity laws,” a more accurate explanation is that eligible offers can be distributed through a private membership environment subject to supplier terms, availability and applicable requirements.
The rates, inventory, savings and benefits available for any particular search can vary based on destination, dates, hotel, room type, supplier availability and other conditions.
Why Comparing Public and Private Travel Offers Matters
Public booking sites are useful tools, but they represent only part of the travel marketplace.
A traveler who qualifies for private, corporate, loyalty or membership offers may have access to additional booking options.
That does not mean the private option will always win on price. It means the traveler has another qualified channel to compare.
Compare the Complete Hotel Offer
When comparing hotel pricing, look beyond the headline room rate.
Compare:
The exact hotel property
Room category
Occupancy
Travel dates
Taxes and fees
Resort or destination fees
Refundability
Cancellation policy
Included amenities
Available member benefits
Final checkout price
Two offers that appear identical at first glance can have different booking terms.
Is Rate Parity the Same Everywhere in the World?
No.
The contractual and legal treatment of hotel rate-parity provisions differs among jurisdictions and continues to evolve.
Some countries or jurisdictions have restricted particular parity arrangements, while other markets may permit different forms of contractual distribution arrangements.
For this reason, broad statements about one worldwide “rate parity law” should be avoided.
The Bottom Line
Hotel rate parity is not one universal worldwide law.
It generally describes contractual provisions, pricing practices or distribution arrangements involving how certain hotel rates are advertised or distributed.
Public hotel rates and eligible private member offers can operate through different distribution channels.
A private membership does not guarantee that every hotel will always be cheaper. It can provide eligible travelers access to participating private offers that may not be available through an ordinary unrestricted public search.
Frequently Asked Questions About Hotel Rate Parity
Is hotel rate parity a law?
No, not as one universal worldwide law. Rate parity commonly refers to contractual provisions and hotel distribution practices. Laws and regulations affecting those arrangements vary by jurisdiction.
What is a private hotel rate?
A private hotel rate or offer is distributed through a restricted or qualified channel rather than being available in exactly the same way to the unrestricted public. Eligibility may require membership, authentication or another qualification.
What is a Closed User Group in travel?
A Closed User Group, or CUG, is a defined group of eligible users who can access certain offers within a restricted environment. Membership or authentication generally distinguishes the group from unrestricted public access.
Why do I have to log in to see some Hotels Etc. offers?
Certain member offers may be distributed within an authenticated private membership environment and can be subject to supplier, eligibility and distribution requirements.
Does Hotels Etc. guarantee every hotel will be cheaper?
No. Travel pricing and availability constantly change. Rates and savings vary according to hotel, destination, dates, room type, inventory, supplier availability and other factors.
Are private member rates always better than public rates?
No. Private membership provides another category of eligible offers to compare. Travelers should evaluate the complete booking, including room type, taxes, fees, cancellation terms and any participating benefits.
How long has Hotels Etc. been in business?
Hotels Etc. was founded in 1996 and has provided private membership discounts and travel benefits for decades.
About Hotels Etc.
Hotels Etc. is a private travel and lifestyle discount membership company founded in 1996. Eligible members can access participating travel and lifestyle offers through the private Hotels Etc. membership platform.
Searching the internet for the best hotel discounts is becoming a task that most consumers do not want to tackle. Let us show you how to get the best hotel deal
Travel discounts, Travel Tips 
You must be logged in to post a comment.